HIGH SPEED RAIL: BUILD IT SMART
High Speed Rail is coming to San Diego. We have ONE CHANCE to BUILD IT SMART
environmentally and economically

 

Current plans route the train down I-15 from Escondido, then turn into Rose Canyon off Miramar Rd. along the north side of the existing tracks all the way to downtown. They have also presented a vague concept for a 180' deep tunnel under UTC, homes and businesses that would come out in Rose Canyon near Regents Rd. and runalong the tracks to downtown. BUT THEIR OWN STUDIES say a straight route down I-15 to Qualcomm Stadium will have more riders, is faster and cheaper, has less noise impact, and avoids the sensitive environmental site of Rose Canyon Park. Speak up now to demand a full study of alternate routes

HSR has many positives for the state and the environment, as long as they Build it Smart. We have one chance to do it right, so let's be sure we do!

High Speed Rail will devastate Rose Canyon Park and UC neighborhoods

  • 134 trains per day (every 4-5 minutes during 6-9 am and 4-7 peak hrs)
  • new tracks, overhead wires supported by many large poles
  • Huge noise and visual impacts; increased traffic,big parking garages, unknown effect of massive tunnels
  • Continuous 12 foot high chain link security fence
  • New hill cuts and big retaining walls blocking canyon
  • Massive habitat destruction

  • Canyon Train.jpg

    News and updates

  • Discussion of alternate alignments into the city.(05Feb10) Good case made for Qualcomm route, down to Santa Fe depot.
  • Mayor Jerry Sanders enthusiastic about HSR. SD Union-Trib, 05Feb10.
  • Vigorous discussion on the Daily Kos Blog about HSR in general and San Diego in particular: good overview of different viewpoints. Join in! (04Feb10)
  • New routes proposed at HSRA meeting (NCTimes, 5 Feb 10). At the Board meeting of the California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) in San Diego 2/4/10, new routes were proposed including the Rte 56 corridor and Rte 163 corridor. You can find a copy of the presentation about the San Diego to Los Angeles section (PDF)
  • CA Legislative Analyst strongly criticizes the HSR Authority business plan (PDF of review here), pointing out deficiencies in the response to threats, and failure to address risks of reduced ridership, credit failures, market risk, or government funding risk.
  •  
     

    Past News

    Letters of Support:

  • Letter of support from Lori Saldana, CA Assemblymember from the 76th District
  • Letter of support from Donna Frye and Sherri Lightner, San Diego City Council
  • Letter from John Lee Evans, School Board member, to California HSR authority (PDF)
  • News

  • San Diego News Network (10Jan10): Several San Diego neighborhood activists and elected officials say they oppose plans to build a high-speed rail route capable of handling trains designed to travel at speeds of more than 220 mph through Rose Canyon Open Space Park.
  • Press release from Councilmember Sherri Lightner, 10Nov09
  • News update :(SDNN, 14Nov09) At the urging of the public and City Council members, the California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) has agreed to also study the option of sending the high-speed train along I-15 to Qualcomm stadium, skipping University City
  • LA Times (13Nov09): Local rail and commuter rail projects were removed from California's application for stimulus funding in order to put all the eggs in the HSR basket. That means shovel-ready projects to improve Amtrak, Metrolink, and Coaster service in this heavily used rail corridor were not able to apply for money.
  • 1-15 corridor preferred (SDNN, 10Nov09)
  • How much will it cost? (LA Times 21Oct09)
  • HSR hijacks county funding (SD UnionTrib 14Oct09)
  • Oppostion in N. CA (SF Examiner, 30Apr09)
  •  
     

    What you can do

    Thanks to all of those who sent public comments to the HSR Authority. Please continue to comment in the media and online to make the following points:

  • Demand a full study of the I-15 to Qualcomm Stadium route
  • Oppose High Speed Rail through Rose Canyon
  • Describe how the project would affect you and your concerns
  • Tell them to Build it SMART
  • By email
    Use subject line: LA-SD HST Section via Inland Empire

    Send to:
    comments@hsr.ca.gov

    By Mail
    Mr. Dan Leavitt, Deputy Director
    ATTN: HST Project EIR/EIS
    California High-Speed Rail Authority
    925 L Street, Suite 1425, Sacramento, CA 95814

     
     

    Resources for high speed rail

    How do we calculate 134 trains a day? Using the HSR business plan, they calculate 46 trains one way during the peak hours: 7-8 trains per hour EACH WAY from 6-9am and 4-7pm. (See forecast here, full report here; PDFs). Add those 92 trains to the 42 expected off peak, and you get 134.

    Information, pro and con

  • California High Speed Rail Authority
  • CA High Speed Rail Blog (Pro)
  • High Speed Rail Problems (focused on Northern California)
  • Information and background at City Councilmember Lightner's site
  • California HSR Land Impacts
  • California Rail Foundation
  • Friends of Rose Canyon
  • Train Riders Association of California (See recent newsletter issue about HSR)
  • Press releases

  • Press release from Councilmember Sherri Lightner, 10Nov09